Top Design Subscription Services Compared: Design Pickle, Penji, Superside & More

The design subscription market has exploded in recent years, with dozens of services promising unlimited design for a flat monthly fee. But with so many options, how do you know which one is right for your business?

In this comprehensive guide, we'll compare the top design subscription services in 2025—from budget-friendly options to enterprise-level solutions—so you can make an informed decision.

1. Design Pickle

One of the original design subscription services, Design Pickle has been around since 2015 and processes thousands of requests monthly.

Pricing:

• Graphics ($1,918/month): Unlimited graphic design requests
• Marketing ($3,166/month): Adds motion graphics and video
• Scale (Custom): Enterprise features and dedicated team

Pros:

• Established company with proven track record
• Large designer network
• Good project management platform

Cons:

• Higher pricing than newer competitors
• Quality can be inconsistent
• Less personalized service

2. Penji

Penji offers one of the most affordable entry points in the market, making it popular with startups and small businesses.

Pricing:

• Pro ($499/month): 1 project at a time, 24-48hr turnaround
• Team ($699/month): 2 projects at a time
• Daytime ($999/month): Priority support, faster turnaround

Pros:

• Very affordable entry point
• Good for basic design needs
• User-friendly platform

Cons:

• Quality varies significantly
• Limited to 1-2 active projects
• Less suitable for complex work

3. Superside

Superside positions itself as the premium, enterprise-grade option for larger companies with bigger budgets.

Pricing:

• Custom pricing (typically $5,000+ per month)
• Enterprise contracts required
• Dedicated creative team

Pros:

• Enterprise-grade quality
• Full creative services including strategy
• 24/7 support

Cons:

• Very expensive
• Minimum commitments required
• Overkill for small businesses

4. Designjoy

Run entirely by one designer (Brett Williams), Designjoy offers a boutique, high-touch experience.

Pricing:

• Monthly ($5,995/month): One request at a time, includes Webflow development

Pros:

• Consistent quality from same designer
• High-end, modern aesthetic
• Personal touch

Cons:

• Very expensive
• Limited capacity (often has waitlist)
• Not scalable

5. Flocksy

Flocksy differentiates by offering multiple creative services beyond design, including copywriting and video.

Pricing:

• Team ($1,195/month): Design, copy, and video
• Team Plus ($1,995/month): More capacity
• Team Max ($2,995/month): Maximum output

Pros:

• Multi-service bundle
• Good value for agencies
• Dedicated project manager

Cons:

• Quality varies across services
• Can be overwhelming
• Design quality not top-tier

6. ManyPixels

ManyPixels offers a balance between affordability and dedicated service.

Pricing:

• Starter ($549/month): 1 request at a time
• Pro ($899/month): 2 requests at a time
• Business ($1,299/month): Dedicated designer

Pros:

• Clean, user-friendly platform
• Dedicated designer option
• Good middle-ground pricing

Cons:

• Limited active requests
• Less known brand
• Mixed reviews on turnaround

7. Designgud

We've positioned ourselves to offer premium quality at accessible pricing, with flexibility that larger services can't match.

Pricing:

• Basic ($1,299/month): 1 request at a time, 1-2 day delivery
• Advance ($3,970/month): Unlimited active requests, same-day delivery, dedicated designer

What Makes Us Different:

• Direct Slack communication (no ticket systems)
• No contracts or commitments
• Pause anytime
• Modern, clean design aesthetic
• Personal service from experienced designers

Comparison Table

Here's how these services stack up:

How to Choose

Choose based on your needs:

• Tight budget: Penji or ManyPixels
• Growing business: Designgud or Design Pickle
• Premium quality: Designjoy or Superside
• Need copy + design: Flocksy

Conclusion

The design subscription market offers options for every budget and need. The key is matching your specific requirements—budget, volume, quality expectations, and flexibility needs—to the right service.

We recommend starting with a trial or month-to-month plan to test the waters before committing long-term.

Ready to experience design subscription done right? Try Designgud and see why businesses choose us for unlimited design with fast delivery and flexible terms.